Subjects

Age Ranges

Fab Tools

Topic Tags

Author

In this lesson, students are guided in a structured learning activity (building a 3D bridge). Students go through an iterative process to learn how designs can be developed and improved over time. The core project is building highway bridges. In this learning activity, teams of 2-3 pupils worked on designing bridges. The bridges should accommodate four lanes of traffic under it, and two lanes over it, and the design should be built in 1:500 scale. Afterwards, students test the strength of each bridge by placing weights on top of it until the bridge breaks.

**Materials List**

- Preferably one fast 3D printer per group
- One computer per group
- 3D design software of your choice
- Printed models of trucks and cars in the right scale (optional).
- The STL-files of trucks and cars in the right scale to help the pupils design
- One test station with heavy weights
- A coordinate system large enough to incorporate all designs produced by the class

**Design Files Developed:**

Car Model – __Bil.stl__, __Truck (12).stl__

**Step One: Making the Coordinate System**

TEACHER NOTE: The easiest way to use the coordinate system is to give the students two parameters in the design task (e.g. strength and price) and create the axes. These constraints should give the students a direction but not an ultimate goal, by giving them a direction students will always have the possibility to improve their design. This type of design task and way of using a coordinate system increase the students’ abilities to problem solve. The coordinate system can also be used to construct knowledge.

TEACHER NOTE**: (Optional Anticipatory Set) **Before class, review and print copy of Activity 1 for each student: ** Coordinate Place Four **and

**Essential Question**: What are Cartesian Coordinates? What is the origin of the name?

*Fun Fact: This lesson plan is named after the French natural philosopher and mathematician Nicole Oresme, who used cartesian coordinates before Descartes, from whom they get their name. Oresme used the coordinate system to plot physical attributes, observed in nature, whereas Descartes used it to describe and understand principles of algebra.*

- In whole class, review Khan Academy Introduction to Coordinate Plane: https://www.khanacademy.org/math/algebra/introduction-to-algebra/overview-hist-alg/v/descartes-and-c artesian-coordinates
- Explain the rules of the Coordinate Place Four game. Give students a few moments to examine the game.
- Explain to students that the game will help them learn to locate positions on a grid by naming coordinates. These are ordered pairs of numbers, or in this case, ordered pairs of letters and numbers.
- Students will pair-share ideas about where the class should place the first red marker. Ask students to identify the location of the markers as precisely as possible.
- In small groups, students will complete Worksheet 1. On each grid, students will take turns drawing and numbering the dots at each of the ordered pairs on the list.
- Teacher will walk around the room to each group, checking for understanding and correcting any misconceptions students may have.

**Step Two: Introduce the Iterative Design Process**

**Essential Question**: How can you use the iterative process to construct knowledge to improve designs?

TEACHER NOTE**: **Keep the introduction as short as possible, the students need to create their own experiences and will learn through this. However, sharing some information at the beginning is essential. Review “The Iterative Designer: An approach for structuring a learning activity with a 3D printer, (Reference __Iterative Design PDF __)

*Explain the Goal*– Inform students that the goal of the lesson is to go through an iterative process. Students will learn how designs can be developed and improved over time. The teacher will guide the pupils through six phases and help them construct knowledge to improve their design. First introduce the students to the design task. Hereafter, the pupils will begin the iterative process and design a solution. (see Chart on p. 1 of Iterative Design handout).

*Introduce the Process *-Before students start, they need to know that they will be working through several

iterations, and that the learning activity extends beyond the initial print. Explain to them how they are going to design, print, test, and evaluate their bridges several times, Students also need to know what to do in each phase and how much time they have, in order to regulate their process themselves.

*Introduce the Task *– Finally students need to know the design task and which problem they are solving. Finding a good design task can be hard, and several considerations are necessary. First of all, it is an advantage if the object is small and fast to 3D print, being able to print each iteration within an hour is an advantage. Furthermore, the task should be to solve a problem, but with multiple possible approaches. This can be easier if the task contains some constraints or goals which gives the pupils a direction for their design. Introduce the actual coordinate system you will use for analysis in step five so the students know what the goals are: price and breaking weight are the 2 axes in the coordinate plane.

- Introduce the Design Challenge to the students.
**“In this task students will design a highway bridge where two cars can drive over the bridge and four trucks, two in each direction, can drive under. The bridge must be as strong as possible to avoid accidents and collapses, however, the price must also be taken into account.”** - Students will create a model of a bridge using the six phases of the iterative process:
- Introduction
- Design/Re-Design
- 3D Printing
- Testing
- Evaluation
- Presenting

- Explain to students that designing in a 1:500 scale produces bridges of an adequate size allowing comparison, both with their own previous designs but also with other students’ designs.TEACHER NOTE: Another reason for designing a 1:500 scale model of their bridge design is to keep the printing time down. If you do not have any experience with the printer, you can practice 3D printing the truck and car designs.It will be an advantage to give students models of trucks and cars in the right scale. Both teacher and students can draw them to practice skills in the design tool. Or, students can use the predefined models. These predefined STL models are imported into the workspace of the modeling software, the pupils can use them to “model around” easing the process of getting scales right. However, using these models will limit their use of math, so you have to decide on the learning goals for the activity.
- Have students develop a design for future highway bridges through an iterative process in groups of 2-3. Review stages of iterative process for student understanding and correcting misperceptions.
- Allow each group of students to start their own prints, so they can be in control of the process. Often the bridges need to be rotated in order to 3D print This is also a good opportunity to introduce this concept to the students.

**Step Three: Calculate the price**

- While the model is being printed, students will apply ratios, measurements and cost-benefit analysis to help calculate the budget of their bridge in real life scale.

TEACHER NOTE: There are several different approaches to calculating the price of a bridge. In this lesson, we start by finding the volume of the print, by seeing the 3D printer as a machine which arranges a long cylinder (the filament) into a new shape (the design). When starting the 3D printer the program will most likely inform you about the length of filament which will be used on this design, and the height (h) of the cylinder. On the spool of filament you can find the diameter (most likely 1,75mm or 2,85mm), which can be converted into the radius (r).

*V **model *= π · *r*2 · *h*

- Volume of Cylinder (model of bridge)= π ⋅ r^2 ⋅ h.

Since the bridge is designed in 1:500 scale (s) on all three axes:

*V **bridge *= π · *r*2 · *h *· *s*3

- Volume of Bridge=(π ⋅ r ^2⋅h)⋅ 500 ^3.

The next step is to multiply the volume of the real life bridge with the price (p) of the material in which the bridge will be built. This lesson used the price of Steel Fiber Concrete on 1.831 Danish Kroners pr. m3

*P **bridge *= π · *r*2 · *h *· *s*3 · *p*

- Price of Bridge=(π ⋅ r^2 ⋅ h) ⋅ 500^3 ⋅ (Price of material pr.m^3)

Example: With a filament radius (r) of 0,00175 meters (Converted from mm to keep units the same), and 2,5 meters of filament used (h), a scale factor of 1:500 (s), and a price per *m*3 alculation will be as follows:

And the price of materials for building this bridge in real life is 191.406$.

TEACHER NOTE: When adapting lesson, teacher should decide to price materials to construct a bridge in real life.

**Step Four: Test the strength**

- After the bridge is finished it is time to test the strength of the Have students place weight on the 3D printed model to get an understanding of the durability of their design. Designate an area of the classroom as the testing zone. (Make sure all 3D printed support material is cleared away for accurate testing).
- Use stacks of paper to measure the durability, but other heavy elements would do just as well. Just be prepared that some of the bridges hold over 100kg.
- Have students share the weights and take turns in testing the durability of their design.
- Tell students not to be afraid of failing, because the purpose is to investigate failures– and learn from them. Tell students the bridges
**MUST FAIL**, and weight should be added until it breaks. - Once a student’s bridge collapses, the student should record the failing weight for the evaluation process

**Step Five: Evaluating and Presenting**

**Essential Question: **How does failure improve the design process?

- Review the coordinate plane, checking for student understanding and misconceptions.
- In whole class, tell students “when you know the price of the bridge and the strength of the model write it on a post-it and place it on the coordinate system.”
- Remind students that the X-axis is the price and the Y-axis is the strength, which means that a strong design with a low price places the design in the top-left part of coordinate system.
- In small groups, help students place their post-it and failed model on the coordinate system. Then, ask students where their next iteration should be placed and discuss what they can do to achieve that goal.
- Have students study weak spots on their design, in order to find where their design needs improvement.

TEACHER NOTE: This is usually the time where the teacher can have very interesting and deep conversations with the student, where knowledge construction can be achieved. Remember not to give your own suggestions on how exactly to improve the design, but have the pupils discover this for themselves.

**Step Six: Presentation**

- After several iterations, the students will end the lesson with presentations of their work.
- Students debate which of their designs are the best and give reasons.
- Extend this activity by testing the models to see which one can support the most weight.
- Provide students with a third piece of paper and have them list other structural elements that would increase their bridge support. At what cost?
- Ask students what structural elements they might add to make their bridge support even more weight.
- Host a class competition to find out which bridge is the strongest.

**Formative Assessment: **Students will be able to explain the process they used to determine the type of bridge that would work best; how they constructed it; and the results of their weight load test.

**More documentation on Facilitation / Procedures**: The iterative designer.compressed.pdf

**NGSS Engineering Design Standards**

- Engineering Design 3-5-ETS1-1: Define a simple design problem reflecting a need or a want that includes specific criteria for success and constraints on materials, time, or cost.
- Engineering Design 3-5-ETS1-2: Generate and compare multiple possible solutions to a problem, based on how well each is likely to meet the criteria and constraints of the problem.
- Engineering Design 3-5-ETS1-3: Plan and carry out fair tests in which variables are controlled and failure points are considered to identify aspects of a model that can be improved.
- MS.Engineering Design MS-ETS1-1: Define the criteria and constraints of a design problem with sufficient precision to ensure a successful solution, taking into account relevant scientific principles and potential impacts on people and the environment that may limit possible solutions.
- MS.Engineering Design MS-ETS1-2: Evaluate competing design solutions using a systemic process to determine how well they meet the criteria and constraints of the problem.
- MS.Engineering Design MS-ETS1-3: Analyze data from tests to determine similarities and differences among several design solutions to identify the best characteristics of each that can be combined into a new solution to better meet the criteria for success.
- MS.Engineering Design MS-ETS1-4: Develop a model to generate data for iterative testing and modification of a proposed object, tool, or process such that an optimal design can be achieved.

**Common Core Math Practices**

MP.1- Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them. MP.2 -Reason abstractly and quantitatively.

MP.3- Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others.

MP.4- Model with mathematics.

MP.5-Use appropriate tools strategically. MP.6- Attend to precision.

MP.7- Look for and make use of structure.

MP.8- Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning.

**Common Core Mathematics Standards**

5.G.A.1. Use a pair of perpendicular number lines, called axes, to define a coordinate system, with the intersection of the lines (the origin) arranged to coincide with the 0 on each line and a given point in the plane located by using an ordered pair of numbers, called its coordinates.

5.NBT.5: Fluently multiply multi-digit whole numbers using standard algorithm.

6.RP.1: Understand the concept of a ratio and use ratio language to describe a ratio relationship between two quantities.

6.RP.3-b: Solve unit rate problems including those involving pricing and constant speed.

6.RP3-d: Use ratio reasoning to convert measurement units; manipulate and transform units appropriately when multiplying or dividing.

**OTHER: I can statement (by contributor)**

This lesson covers each aspect of the revised Bloom’s Taxonomy. Defined as I can:

- Remember: Retrieving, recognizing, and recalling relevant knowledge from long-term memory.
- Understand: Constructing meaning from oral, written, and graphic messages through interpreting, exemplifying, classifying, summarizing, inferring, comparing, and explaining.
- Apply: Carrying out or using a procedure through executing, or implementing.
- Analyze: Breaking material into constituent parts, determining how the parts relate to one another and to an overall structure or purpose through differentiating, organizing, and attributing.
- Evaluate: Making judgments based on criteria and standards through checking and critiquing.
- Create: Putting elements together to form a coherent or functional whole; reorganizing elements

**Digital Fabrication Competencies: I Can Statements**

- (S.2)
*Safety*: I can operate equipment in a Fab Lab following safety protocols. - (DP.2)
*Design Process*: I can design something in a Fab Lab using a specific process under close instructor guidance. - (DP.3)
*Design Process*: I can create analog models (e.g. sketches, small physical models, ) to facilitate a design process. - (DP.5)
*Design Process*: I can work with a group to follow multiple common design process steps (e.g. defining the user, brainstorming, prototyping, iterating, etc.). - (CAD.3)
*Computer Aided Design*: I can draw a basic design using any 3D CAD software. - (CAD.7)
*Computer Aided Design*: I can design a part to be fabricated in 3D with dimensional precision and with fabrication tolerances within 3D software. - (MO.2)
*Machine Operation*: I can safely operate a digital fabrication machine under close observation of an instructor. - (F.4)
*Fabrication*: I can fabricate components of my own design using a single digital fabrication process. - (SC.2)
*Sustainability and Commerce*: I can estimate how much something I made in a Fab Lab costs in raw materials. - (CT.2)
*Critical Thinking*: I can identify the design problem, investigation, or challenge. - (Q.2)
*Questioning*: I can formulate questions that reveal important aspects of design process including problems and challenges. - (PS.2)
*Proposed Solution*: I can test selected solutions or approaches to meet the challenge of design problem.